« It's Baaack: Paycheck Fairness Act Returns to Capitol Hill | Main | Beware the Market Pricing Shortcut: Don't Short Shrift Your Review of the Data »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451df4569e20120a94f5ffc970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Incentives as Your Worst First Solution... & Switch:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

posted this over on paul's blog, too:

Gotta find that classic flow chart of Geary Rummler's on the Performance Model, maybe 30 years old by now or older. Anyone seen it recently? Dealt with those who simply CAN'T and those who just WON'T do what you wish.

Correcting Deficient Performance may have been an alternate title, since it starts out focusing on the performance deficiency and runs thru the entire cycle: properly communicated, understood, has done it before and demonstrated past proficiency, good timely/accurate feedback, no task interference, no competing tasks, adequate resources (time, cost, $, support) ... before eventually finally reaching the biggie... BALANCE of CONSEQUENCES where motivations and incentives are addressed.

Most issues are not solved by training or yelling about motivation but by the other points above, particularly those dealing with those who CAN do it but WON'T because ... (I'll skip the specifics but you all know them...)

Seems it was in my (first) childhood I learned the biggest problem with incentives is not that they won't work but that the DO work all too well. People only do what THEY find to be most rewarding.

P.S. Paul H. was kind enough to post a link to a 12/8/2008 Business Process Trends Vol. 6, #21 report on Geary A. Rummler's passing that contained text of the Performance Model.

I did not find any new ideas in Switch and I'm surprised at its popularity. A better title would be Bait and Switch, since the ideas don't match the hype.

The best book on organizational change for me is Jack Welch's Straight From the Gut, in which he describes how he successfully transformed GE.

Not surprised, because I'd bet the vast majority of folks today were not active in business in 1980 when Welch took over GE. That era is actually more antiquely remote to them than The Great Depression was to me.

Jim:

Can you share a link to that model here?

Mario:

Interesting perspective. It's been awhile (maybe quite awhile) since I read "Straight from the Gut" but I don't recall being that impressed with it. Perhaps I should take another look. Or perhaps we just have to admit to having different takes - I find the framework presented in Switch to be helpful, especially for those of us in the reward field who are often tempted to focus too narrowly on incentives and financial triggers.

Thanks for the comments here!

http://www.bptrends.com/publicationfiles/advisor20081209.pdf

I sent this to Paul in greatful reponse:

God bless you, thank you, thank you, thank you.... that IS it, but just not in the simpler flowchart branching into CAN'T and WON'T paths that I used to teach in my OD days in the 1970s. I could probably recreate it from those refresher cues. That version mostly simply lacks the options recommended when the answer is NO; and neither training nor rewards are usually useful corrective/remedial methods for those issues.

Bottom line, though: I had to spend my years as a compensation specialist before I had the credibility to be able to disprove and dismiss pay as the universal solution, so folks could get down to the REAL root causes of performance problems. Until you can eliminate compensation as the fast quick fix, you waste much money and solve few problems.

Sorry, Ann, I must agree with Mario on this one. I have read Switch and found little of substance there. The connection of the ideas with incentives is strained at best.

Clive Wilson, CCP

Clive:

Thanks for weighing in. Interesting to hear others' takes. And I agree that the connection with incentives is light - but that's not what I liked about the book. I get involved in SO many situations where organizations are trying to solve performance/change issues with financial incentives that I really appreciate the framework that the Heath bros. offer for examining the roots and possible solutions to a problem outside the realm of pay.

Just my take.

Others?

The comments to this entry are closed.

About The Author

  • More Info Here
    Compensation consultant Ann Bares is the Managing Partner of Altura Consulting Group. Ann has more than 20 years of experience consulting with organizations in the areas of compensation and performance management.

Compensation Force Spot Survey

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Search This Site

Widgetbox

  • Get this widget from Widgetbox